Series · The Emergent Stupidity
The Stupidity No One Chose
Bonhoeffer saw that people are made stupid. I think our systems now do it with no one in charge, through delegation, insulation, and alignment.

Three copies and a carbon
At the turn of the year 1942 to 1943, the theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer typed an essay with carbon copies. For two years he had worked inside German military intelligence, which was, as his English editor puts it, "also the heart of the conspiracy" against Hitler. Germany had been under Nazi rule for ten years. He called the essay "After Ten Years."
He gave three copies as Christmas presents: to his brother-in-law Hans von Dohnanyi, Major General Hans Oster, and his close friend Eberhard Bethge. The typescript carries a note in Bethge's hand: "Christmas 1942." One carbon copy was hidden between the rafters of his parents' house in Berlin.
On April 5, 1943, the Gestapo arrested him in that house. On April 8, 1945, he was brought to the Flossenbürg concentration camp, tried that evening by what his editor calls "a hastily rigged court," and executed early the next morning. Only the copy in the rafters survived the war. Bethge, who lived to edit it and write Bonhoeffer's biography, predicted it would be read long after the resistance's drafts for constitutions were forgotten.
Partway through, a short section on stupidity opens:
"Stupidity is a more dangerous enemy of the good than malice."
The essay is often said to have been written in prison. It was written months before the arrest, by a free man, about the people around him; it later opened Letters and Papers from Prison, which may be how it got moved into a cell. Nor did Bonhoeffer exempt his own circle: "we have encountered much bravery and self-sacrifice," he wrote, "but almost no civil courage anywhere, even among ourselves."
The sentence at the center
The essay has no salutation or closing (his biographer Charles Marsh reads it as an essay, not a letter) and runs in short sections, from Who Stands Firm? to Are We Still of Any Use? Read whole, On Stupidity makes four moves.
Nothing reaches it. Evil "leaves behind in human beings at least a sense of unease." But "against stupidity we are defenseless." Reasons "fall on deaf ears." Inconvenient facts are disbelieved or waved away, and the stupid person stays "utterly self-satisfied."
It is not about intelligence. Stupidity is "not an intellectual defect but a human one." "There are human beings who are of remarkably agile intellect yet stupid, and others who are intellectually quite dull yet anything but stupid."
It is made. His impression was "not so much that stupidity is a congenital defect but that, under certain circumstances, people are made stupid or that they allow this to happen to them." In the first German edition, gemacht (made) is letter-spaced for emphasis. Solitary people show it less often than those "inclined or condemned to sociability." Then the sentence at the center:
"And so it would seem that stupidity is perhaps less a psychological than a sociological problem."
Power drives it. "Every strong upsurge of power in the public sphere, be it of a political or a religious nature, infects a large part of humankind with stupidity." Note the "or": no single side owns this. "The power of the one needs the stupidity of the other."
A consolation follows: these thoughts "utterly forbid us to consider the majority of people to be stupid in every circumstance." The next section adds: "Nothing of what we despise in another is itself foreign to us." His English editors note that the section uses "stupidity" as "a psychological characteristic of Hitler and his followers," and cite his Ethics on the tyrant who despises people: "He considers the people stupid and they become stupid." Contempt is one of the ways stupidity gets made.
Victoria Barnett opens her 2017 edition with a caution: "One must be cautious about drawing simplistic historical analogies." This series borrows an insight, not a comparison.
Here is the question. Bonhoeffer's stupidity had a driver: somebody's rising power. What happens when there is no "one"? Can a system of decent, intelligent people produce a stupidity none of them chose? I think it can, and that the first defense is learning to see it, starting with ourselves.
What stupidity is not
"Stupid" is a word we mostly aim at other people, so care is needed. Two of Bonhoeffer's contemporaries drew the same line. In Vienna in 1937, the novelist Robert Musil lectured "On Stupidity." He set "an honest and simple stupidity" against another kind that is, "a little paradoxically, even a sign of intelligence," and judged the second "by far the more dangerous." (Musil translations are mine.)
Hannah Arendt, who reported on the Eichmann trial, drew the line from the other side. In 1971 she described not a monster but a man with "a curious, quite authentic inability to think," and later, in The Life of the Mind, was exact: "it was not stupidity but thoughtlessness." She kept "stupidity" for the intellectual kind; Bonhoeffer stripped the intellect out of his. I think they name the same failure, one she called "so ordinary an experience in our everyday life." Her portrait of Eichmann is disputed, notably by David Cesarani and Bettina Stangneth; the concept has outlived the dispute.
Carlo M. Cipolla's satirical "The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity" (1976) holds that the probability someone is stupid "is independent of any other characteristic of that person." Bonhoeffer says the share moves with circumstances. So do I.
The working definition: stupidity is a failure to think when thinking is possible and needed. Not low intelligence, not ignorance, not a mistake. And no one is exempt. "Now and then we are all stupid," Musil said, and each of us should hunt it in ourselves first, not only in its great historical eruptions.
The machinery
Bonhoeffer described how people are made stupid. This series describes the machinery: what the systems around us do that makes thinking optional. Read beside older texts, his section shows three mechanisms, which this series calls delegation, insulation, and alignment. The names are this series' own, not his. Each is something a structure does: what a system offers, what it provides, what it rewards.
That moves the question from people to arrangements. A trait belongs to a person and invites blame. A mechanism works on anyone inside it, the writer included.
Delegation: what a system offers. A default authority that makes handing over judgment the easy path: a tool, a ranking, a procedure, a model, a boss. The stupid person is often stubborn, Bonhoeffer wrote, but "he is not independent"; one deals "not at all with him as a person, but with slogans, catchwords, and the like that have taken possession of him." Having become "a mindless tool," he is "capable of any evil." In 1784 Immanuel Kant described the offer itself (Lewis White Beck's translation): "If I have a book which understands for me, a pastor who has a conscience for me, a physician who decides my diet, and so forth, I need not trouble myself. I need not think, if I can only pay: others will easily undertake the irksome work for me." He blamed "laziness and cowardice." A system needs neither; it only has to make the handover easier than the thinking. Now the book talks back. Part II takes it up.
Insulation: what a system provides. Distance between a decision and the inconvenient fact: filters, dashboards, summaries, schedules, and incentives that keep a fact from arriving, or from mattering when it does. Bonhoeffer saw insulation from the inside: facts that contradict one's prejudgment "simply need not be believed," and when they cannot be denied, "they are just pushed aside as inconsequential, as incidental." A system does both jobs for us. It filters the fact out, or files it where no decision will meet it.
Plato had a word for the inner version: amathia, which the Greek lexicon glosses as "ignorance, stupidity," even "wilful blindness." In the Laws, the greatest amathia belongs to the man "who hates, instead of loving, what he judges to be noble and good" (R. G. Bury's translation): judgment says one thing, desire another, and desire wins. It can afflict even "expert calculators," trained "in everything that fosters agility of soul." Bonhoeffer's "agile intellect yet stupid" has old roots. Amathia is insulation built inside one mind; systems build it outside, for many minds at once. Part VI goes deeper.
Alignment: what a system rewards. Moving with the group: metrics, likes, careers, consensus. Bonhoeffer: "under the overwhelming impact of rising power, humans are deprived of their inner independence and, more or less consciously, give up establishing an autonomous position." More or less consciously: nobody has to decide to go along. Four centuries earlier, Étienne de La Boétie saw that one man cannot rule millions without them: the tyrant has "nothing more than the power that you confer upon him to destroy you" (Harry Kurz's translation). He also saw what keeps people conferring it: a chain of favorites, six hundred "who profit under them" and six thousand "whom they promote in rank." Musil saw alignment in miniature: the urge to feel superior, he said, loses all shame once it can shelter under a party, nation, sect, or artistic movement and say "We" instead of "I."
The irony is that alignment is a word organizations celebrate, often rightly: a team pulling one way gets things built. It turns into a mechanism of stupidity when going along pays more reliably than being right.
This series says "we" constantly. Take Musil's point as a warning: the "we" here is an admission, not a shelter.
More is different
In "More Is Different" (Science, 1972), the physicist P. W. Anderson wrote that "at each level of complexity entirely new properties appear." An emergent property belongs to the whole and to none of the parts. No single car contains a traffic jam.
Emergent stupidity is that idea applied to thinking: a system of individually sensible people producing a collectively senseless result. Nobody chose it. Everybody does it.
Look again at "The power of the one needs the stupidity of the other." The German is plural, Die Macht der einen braucht die Dummheit der anderen: the power of some needs the stupidity of others (my translation). La Boétie's chain of favorites runs the same way, down to "even millions." Either way, the chain has a knot at the top: someone whose power needs the stupidity.
Here is the step this series takes. Untie the knot, and the chain can still hold: stupidity produced by structure alone, with no one at the top who needs it. What holds it is the machinery: delegation, insulation, and alignment, run by everyone and owned by no one. Bonhoeffer described stupidity as the by-product of someone's power. Emergent stupidity is the by-product of everyone's convenience.
In a 2011 experiment with 144 participants, Jan Lorenz and colleagues at ETH Zurich found that seeing one another's estimates made opinions converge and confidence rise "despite lack of improved accuracy." In 2017, Joshua Becker, Devon Brackbill, and Damon Centola showed that it depends on the wiring: in decentralized networks, sharing made groups more accurate; in centralized ones dominated by a few, group error became more likely to rise. The structure decides. The stupidity, and the wisdom, belong to the whole.
Why nobody chose it
Each step is small and sensible. The tool is usually right. The report is long and the meeting starts in ten minutes. The room seems sure. One step for each mechanism, and each pays off at once. The cost is deferred and spread out: it lands later, on someone else, or on everyone a little. That asymmetry is the engine. Then the loops close. What we delegate, we practice less. What we are shielded from, we lose the ability to see. What the system rewards, it gets more of. None of it needs a villain.
Bonhoeffer ends his section with a condition: "It really will depend on whether those in power expect more from peoples' stupidity than from their inner independence and wisdom." Widen its subject, and it still holds: it will depend on whether the systems we build expect more from our stupidity than from our independence.
More and more
Nobody measures emergent stupidity directly, so my claim is narrow: it is rising not because people are getting dumber, but because the systems we live inside run all three mechanisms more and more. Delegation is cheaper: a prompt costs nothing, and early, self-reported research suggests that the more we trust the tool, the less we check it. Insulation is thicker: more of what we know arrives summarized, ranked, and filtered, and a fluent answer rarely mentions what it left out. Alignment is faster: a feed assembles a crowd in minutes, and the crowd never has to meet.
The cost today is mostly invisible: errors nobody catches because everyone assumed someone else had checked. The risk, if the trend runs on for five or ten more years, is not a dumber species but institutions that lose the habits that catch mistakes: asking, reading the inconvenient report, saying "I don't think so" in a room. That is a forecast, not a finding; the season tests it.
Noticing it
Bonhoeffer thought no one could be lectured out of stupidity: "only an act of liberation, not instruction, can overcome stupidity." His own answer was theological, an inner liberation "to live the responsible life before God." This series borrows his diagnosis, not his theology, but it keeps his word responsible.
So no lecture. Just four questions, the Three Checks and the Scale Question, for ourselves first.
- The delegation check. Whose judgment am I running on right now? Did I choose it, or was it simply the default?
- The insulation check. What would I prefer not to find out, and what is keeping it from me? Did I build that wall, or just stop noticing it?
- The alignment check. Would I still believe this if the people around me did not? Would I say it out loud if nobody agreed?
- The Scale Question. If everyone did exactly what I am doing, what would the whole become?
A practice for this week: the source line. Once a day, write one sentence: a judgment you acted on, and where it came from. If one of the three mechanisms was at work, mark it D, I, or A. Do not grade yourself. At the end of the week, look at the letters.
The aim is not to stop trusting anyone. Musil was clear that we must sometimes act blind or half-blind, or the world would stand still. The aim is to know which trust you chose.
The season ahead
Every Wednesday, one domain: how a reasonable step becomes an unreasonable whole. Each part joins the series page as it publishes:
- II. The Last Thought You Had Yourself: thinking, tools, and AI.
- III. Computer Says No: institutions that trust their systems more than their people.
- IV. Everyone in the Room Knew: work, and the meeting where everyone saw it and nobody said it.
- V. A Crowd That Never Meets: feeds, attention, and alignment without a room.
- VI. Smart Enough to Fool Ourselves: belief, identity, and why intelligence is no protection.
- VII. The Five-Sentence Letter: medicine, and how repetition becomes settled fact.
- VIII. The Copy of a Copy: machines that learn from machines.
- Then: What You Saw. Your sightings, and the results of a small reader experiment that opens with Part V.
One sighting
Near the end of "After Ten Years," Bonhoeffer asks his friends: "Are we still of any use?" Part of his answer: "We will not need geniuses, cynics, people who have contempt for others, or cunning tacticians, but simple, uncomplicated, and honest human beings." I think it starts with noticing. Hence the ask that ends every part.
Send me one sighting. One place you saw emergent stupidity at work this week, in your own field: a system of sensible people producing a result none of them would sign. No names, no shaming. Leave it in the comments here (free subscribers can comment) or write to hello@nanosava.com. I read every sighting, and the best ones, anonymous unless you say otherwise, will shape later parts.
Sources
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer, "After Ten Years," prologue to Letters and Papers from Prison, Dietrich Bonhoeffer Works (English), vol. 8, ed. John W. de Gruchy, Fortress Press, 2010; "After Ten Years" translated by Barbara and Martin Rumscheidt, with the editors' notes (Bethge's handwritten "Christmas 1942" on the typescript; the note on "stupidity" and the Ethics). Publisher's sample of the prologue: https://ms.fortresspress.com/downloads/0800697030Prologue.pdf Translation note: quotations from "After Ten Years" follow this translation, checked against the German (sources 2 and 3). Translations from German marked "my translation," and all translations from Musil, are mine.
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer, "Nach zehn Jahren," in Widerstand und Ergebung, Dietrich Bonhoeffer Werke, vol. 8, Gütersloh, 1998, pp. 19 to 39 (page reference per source 9).
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer, "Von der Dummheit," in Widerstand und Ergebung: Briefe und Aufzeichnungen aus der Haft, ed. Eberhard Bethge, Chr. Kaiser, Munich, 1951, pp. 17 to 20; transcription with page scans, Wikisource. https://de.wikisource.org/wiki/Von_der_Dummheit (the plural "der einen ... der anderen"; the letter-spaced "gemacht")
- John W. de Gruchy, "Editor's Introduction to the English Edition," Letters and Papers from Prison, DBWE 8, Fortress Press, 2010. Publisher's sample: https://ms.fortresspress.com/downloads/0800697030Intro.pdf (written for Bethge, Dohnanyi, and Oster at Christmas 1942, a few months before the imprisonment; placed by Bethge at the head of later editions; the arrest on April 5, 1943; Flossenbürg and "a hastily rigged court")
- John W. de Gruchy, "Editor's Introduction to the Reader's Edition," Letters and Papers from Prison, Fortress Press, 2015. https://ms.fortresspress.com/downloads/9781506402741_Editor's%20Introduction%20to%20the%20Reader's%20Edition.pdf (two years in military intelligence, "also the heart of the conspiracy"; Bethge as editor and biographer)
- Victoria J. Barnett, ed., "After Ten Years": Dietrich Bonhoeffer and Our Times, Fortress Press, 2017, with Barnett's introduction, "Reading Bonhoeffer's 'After Ten Years' in Our Times," and the Rumscheidt translation. Publisher's excerpts: https://ms.fortresspress.com/downloads/9781506433387%20After%20Ten%20Years%20FINAL-IntroductionExcerpt.pdf and https://ms.fortresspress.com/downloads/9781506433387%20After%20Ten%20Years%20FINAL-excerpt.pdf
- Charles Marsh, "'Are We Still of Any Use?' Dietrich Bonhoeffer on Christian Witness in a Perilous Age," Project on Lived Theology, University of Virginia, 2023. https://www.livedtheology.org/theology-now/are-we-still-of-any-use/ (no salutation or closing: an essay, not a letter). Marsh is the author of Strange Glory: A Life of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Knopf, 2014.
- Eberhard Bethge, Dietrich Bonhoeffer (rowohlts monographien), Rowohlt, Reinbek bei Hamburg, 1976, as quoted in source 9 (the essay will still be read when the resistance's drafts for constitutions and organizations are long forgotten).
- Mitsuo Miyata, with Ilse Tödt, "Analyse der geistigen Situation zur Zeit des Nationalsozialismus: Eine Einführung zu Bonhoeffers Rechenschaft 'Nach zehn Jahren'," Internationale Bonhoeffer-Gesellschaft, 2023 (from Miyata's book, Iwanami, Tokyo, 2019). https://www.Dietrich-Bonhoeffer.net/fileadmin/media/ibg/2023_08_31b_korr_Nach_zehn_Jahren_mmiyata.pdf (carbon copies; the three gifts; the copy hidden between the rafters, the only one to survive; Bethge's release in April 1945)
- Bonhoeffer-Haus Berlin, "House" and "More important than ever in these times," 2026. https://www.bonhoeffer-haus-berlin.de/en/site-and-history/house/ and https://www.bonhoeffer-haus-berlin.de/en/news/more-important-than-ever-in-these-times/ (the arrest at his parents' house)
- Immanuel Kant, "An Answer to the Question: What Is Enlightenment?" (1784), trans. Lewis White Beck, in Kant, On History, Bobbs-Merrill, 1963; text at Wikisource. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/What_is_Enlightenment%3F German original: "Beantwortung der Frage: Was ist Aufklärung?," Berlinische Monatsschrift, December 1784, Wikisource. https://de.wikisource.org/wiki/Beantwortung_der_Frage:_Was_ist_Aufkl%C3%A4rung%3F
- Plato, Laws 3.689a to d, trans. R. G. Bury, Perseus Digital Library. https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0166%3Abook%3D3%3Apage%3D689 Greek text: https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0165%3Abook%3D3%3Apage%3D689
- Liddell, Scott, and Jones, A Greek-English Lexicon, entry "ἀμαθία," Perseus Digital Library. https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.04.0057%3Aentry%3Da%29maqi%2Fa
- Étienne de La Boétie, Discourse on Voluntary Servitude, written in the mid-sixteenth century and printed anonymously in the 1570s, trans. Harry Kurz, Columbia University Press, 1942 (as Anti-Dictator); online text, Constitution Society. https://www.constitution.org/2-Authors/la_boetie/serv_vol.htm
- Robert Musil, "Über die Dummheit," lecture for the Austrian Werkbund, Vienna, March 11 and 17, 1937, Projekt Gutenberg. https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/robert-musil/books/ueber-die-dummheit/chapter/2 (translations mine)
- Tatjana Tömmel and Maurizio Passerin d'Entrèves, "Hannah Arendt," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, revised 2024. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/arendt/ (Arendt's "a curious, quite authentic inability to think," cited to "Thinking and Moral Considerations: A Lecture," Social Research 38, no. 3, 1971, p. 417)
- Jon Nixon, "Hannah Arendt: thinking versus evil," Times Higher Education, February 26, 2015. https://www.timeshighereducation.com/features/hannah-arendt-thinking-versus-evil/2018664.article (quoting The Life of the Mind: "not stupidity but thoughtlessness" and "so ordinary an experience in our everyday life")
- "Eichmann in Jerusalem," Wikipedia, accessed 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eichmann_in_Jerusalem (summary of the criticism by David Cesarani, Becoming Eichmann, 2006, and Bettina Stangneth, Eichmann Before Jerusalem, 2014; secondary source)
- Carlo M. Cipolla, "The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity," reprinted in Whole Earth Review, 1987; archived text. https://web.archive.org/web/20130216132858/http://www.cantrip.org/stupidity.html (date of 1976 per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_M._Cipolla)
- P. W. Anderson, "More Is Different," Science 177, no. 4047, 1972. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.177.4047.393
- Jan Lorenz, Heiko Rauhut, Frank Schweitzer, and Dirk Helbing, "How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108, no. 22, 2011. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1008636108
- Joshua Becker, Devon Brackbill, and Damon Centola, "Network dynamics of social influence in the wisdom of crowds," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, no. 26, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1615978114
- Hao-Ping (Hank) Lee, Advait Sarkar, Lev Tankelevitch, Ian Drosos, Sean Rintel, Richard Banks, and Nicholas Wilson, "The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking: Self-Reported Reductions in Cognitive Effort and Confidence Effects From a Survey of Knowledge Workers," CHI 2025. https://doi.org/10.1145/3706598.3713778
- Further reading: Big Think, "The 3 elements of stupidity, according to philosophy | Jonny Thomson: Full Interview," YouTube, July 2026. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbQ-t8GXYTA